In Wisconsin, over 284,000 homes — equal to roughly 11.71% of households — rely on propane gas for their home heating. The main source of residential heating in Wisconsin is utility gas, which accounts for 65.47% of all households’ heat fuel. The second most popular is electric heating, which accounts for 16.73% of households. In addition to residential use, propane is utilized on a large scale in Wisconsin for commercial and agricultural purposes.
Whether you’re heating your home, fueling your business, or powering agricultural operations, read on to discover the top propane companies in Wisconsin that stand out for their service, reliability, and commitment to their customers. Get quotes from up to 5 propane dealers in your area today to get the best pricing on propane delivery.
Table of Contents
Best propane companies in Wisconsin
In order to compile our list of the best propane companies in Wisconsin, we evaluated all propane providers against a rigorous criterion. It included whether the company offers residential delivery and commercial delivery; if they perform propane tank installations; if they offer propane-related and propane-powered appliances, ranging from propane generators to larger appliances like patio furnaces; commercial services, especially temporary heating for jobsites and forklift services; as well as service area coverage and if they offer additional fuels, such as home heating oil.
So, check out our final list of the best propane companies in Wisconsin below:
Chippewa Valley Energy
- 7133 US-12, Eau Claire, WI 54703 | 715-876-6400
Headquartered in Eau Claire, Wisconsin, Chippewa Valley Energy services parts of 16 counties in West Central and Northwest Wisconsin. This propane provider ranked among the best propane companies in Wisconsin thanks to its breadth of services. Chippewa Valley Energy has flexible options for homeowners when it comes to propane tanks. If you are considering leasing a tank from Chippewa Valley Energy, you have a variety of sizes to choose from, ranging from 123 to 1000 gallons. Leasing a tank is an affordable option that eliminates the need for you to handle maintenance.
Their team of Customer Service Specialists will help you select the best propane tank to fit your needs. You can lease tanks without any annual fees as long as you meet the yearly usage requirements, which vary by tank size. For instance, a 123-gallon tank requires a minimum yearly usage of 200 gallons, while a 1000-gallon tank requires 1600 gallons annually.
On the other hand, owning your own tank means you are responsible for all maintenance to keep it up to code. This includes both above-ground and below-ground propane tanks. In addition to tank services, Chippewa Valley Energy offers a comprehensive home heating program featuring Cenex Premium Home Heating Fuels. We provide exceptional service, competitive prices, and high-quality fuels, including #1 Diesel and #2 Diesel for home heating applications.
Garrow Oil & Propane
- 504 W Edgewood Dr, Appleton, WI 54913 | 920-733-8877
Garrow Oil & Propane has been one of the most trust propane companies for some time, serving to Appleton and surrounding communities for over 50 years. It’s also one of the best propane companies in Wisconsin. Their experienced professionals deliver quality propane for residential, commercial, industrial, and agricultural applications, ensuring you have access to propane when you need it most with their 24-hour service.
Whether you need propane in Oshkosh or any other service area, the Garrow Oil & Propane team is ready to help. They offer a range of propane services including LP tanks, forklift fuel, construction heat, cylinder and RV filling, auto-delivery, DOT recertification, and custom-made hoses and repairs.
For added convenience, Garrow Oil & Propane provides lease-free programs, budget plans, price protection, cash discounts, quantity discounts, and a customer referral program. They offer tanks for lease or purchase in sizes of 120, 330, 500, and 1000 gallons, each with specific annual usage requirements to avoid rental fees. Their team will help determine the appropriate tank size based on your heating needs, square footage, and propane-powered appliances. To purchase a tank, customers must be in their service area, take the first fill from them, and have the tank delivered and installed by their team.
L&L Propane
- N903 WI-22, Waupaca, WI 54981 | 800-924-5975
L&L Propane easily makes our list of the best propane companies in Wisconsin. They offer propane services — the full range, from tank installation to appliance installation — to residential, commercial, and agricultural customers. At L&L Propane, they provide a consistent and hassle-free propane supply, delivering fuel directly to your doorstep to power your home year-round.
They accommodate both 500-gallon and 1000-gallon tanks, equipped with gauges for real-time monitoring of propane levels, ensuring you can effectively track your usage. To maintain uninterrupted service, L&L Propane recommends contacting us when your tank reaches around 40% capacity, with some flexibility during lower usage summer months. Their efficient delivery process aims to provide propane within 5-7 business days of your order. In addition to delivery, L&L Propane offers tank refills, repairs, and old tank removal, with our skilled team ready to meet all your propane-related needs.
Lakes Gas
- 1200 Lake Ave W, Ladysmith, WI 54848 | 715-532-5593
- 602 Louisa St, Crivitz, WI 54114 | 715-854-2701
- E286 WI-54, Luxemburg, WI 54217 | 920-845-5550
- 50 Packer Dr, Roberts, WI 54023 | 715-749-8151
- 1724 W River Dr, Stevens Point, WI 54481 | 715-344-5254
With locations throughout the state, including Ladysmith, Crivitz, Stevens Point, Robers, and Luxemburg, among others, Lakes Gas is family-owned and was founded in 1959. The company offers residential, agricultural, and commercial propane services. They operate in Wisconsin, Minnesota, South Dakota, North Dakota, with some additional markets elsewhere. Last year, Lakes Gas sold an estimated 66.275 million retail gallons of propane. This makes it easily one of the biggest propane companies in the Midwest.
Residential customers can benefit from the convenience of automatic propane delivery from Lakes Gas. This service ensures that their tanks remain full and their homes stay warm without any effort on their part. Additionally, for those who don’t have a propane tank on their property, Lakes Gas offers a leasing option. They will help you determine the appropriate tank size and set up a lease agreement to meet your needs.
Businesses can also take advantage of Lakes Gas’s cost-effective and energy-efficient propane services. These services include providing propane for forklifts, which is safe for indoor use with proper ventilation and offers higher octane ratings. Home builders can incorporate propane into their projects, introducing new homeowners to its benefits for appliances, hot water, and outdoor enhancements.
Moreover, Lakes Gas offers a convenient cylinder exchange program, allowing customers to swap empty tanks for full ones, as well as a propane refill program for retailers to provide on-site cylinder refills.
Milton Propane
- 3992 E Vincent St, Milton, WI 53563 | 800-822-8046
- 2835 Plum Lake Dr., Sayner, WI 54560 | 877-445-3292
- 571 Timber Lane, Rochelle, IL 61068 | 866-562-5999
- 701 East Line Road, Kaukauna, WI 54130 | 800-747-1060
- 1207 Moorman Drive, Waupun, WI 53963 | 800-320-0375
- 2988 Wanek Road, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235 | 888-909-4888
Having been established over 52 years ago, and serving 43 counties, Milton Propane ranks among the best propane companies in Wisconsin. Their fleet of propane trucks is among the largest in the state, with over 50 vehicles. Milton Propane handles everything from installing and delivering small cylinders to 1000-gallon tanks. As a family-owned business, they understand the importance of your home’s comfort and security.
Their range of propane tank sizes includes 120, 250, 325, 500, and 1000-gallon LP tanks. Every residential propane installation comes with a complete safety check performed at the time of installation. Plus, there are no installation fees for tanks 250 gallons or larger, ensuring fast, friendly, and reliable service.
Northwoods Propane
- 2477 16th St, Rice Lake, WI 54868 | 715-236-7718
Northwoods Propane is one of the most well-regarded propane companies. Northwoods Propane has a number of flexible ways to pay. Their Summer Pre-Buy Program allows you to pre-purchase your winter heating gallons at a locked-in price, providing significant savings. By signing this contract, you secure a Price Protection Program, which means if propane prices drop below your contracted price, you will benefit from the lower price during your delivery week. To participate, simply fill out the contract, indicating whether you prefer the Keep Fill or Will Call option, and specify the number of gallons you want to purchase.
If you don’t use all your contracted gallons by April 30th, they will be rolled over as a credit on your account. The Summer Fill Program offers the best pricing of the season, encouraging customers to fill their tanks during this period to ensure they are prepared for winter. During the summer, tanks are filled to 80%, while in the winter, they are filled to 85%.
The Budget Program allows you to spread your propane costs over 12 consistent monthly payments from July to June, making it easier to manage your expenses. By estimating your winter propane usage, they can create a monthly payment plan for you. This program includes the Keep Fill option, where they monitor your tank and deliver propane when it reaches 20-25%. The gallons purchased under this program are locked in at a set price per gallon for the entire year or until all budgeted gallons are delivered.
Additionally, the Fall Pre-Buy Program is your last chance to lock in your winter heating gallons at a set contract price, protecting you from rising winter prices. While this program does not include price protection, it still offers a stable rate for the season. As with the Summer Pre-Buy, any unused contracted gallons by April 30th will be credited to your account.
Superior Fuel
- 24037 Railroad Ave, Siren, WI 54872 | 715-349-2255
Superior Fuel has it where it counts, providing a whole slew of services that help make it one of the best propane companies in Wisconsin. You can lock in ultimate convenience and value with Superior Fuel’s Stable Price Plan, which guarantees a fixed rate for the term of your contract, protecting you from price increases. This plan offers the benefit of convenient monthly payments, helping you avoid unexpected costs and maximize savings during peak heating times.
You can secure a fixed rate for up to 3 years, enjoy equal monthly payments, and set up automatic payments on a date that works for you. Their monitored delivery service ensures you never run out of fuel, backed by a $250 “No Runout Guarantee.” With the Stable Price Plan, you can experience peace of mind and financial stability.
ProPay is a metered propane service designed to simplify managing your propane supply. With ProPay, you only pay for the propane you use, when you use it, not when it’s delivered, eliminating large fills and unexpected bills. Superior Fuel’s advanced monitoring system tracks your propane levels in real-time, allowing us to schedule automatic deliveries so you never have to manually place an order when your supply is low. Each month, you are billed for the propane you used the previous month, making the process straightforward and hassle-free.
What’s more, Superior Fuel specializes in comprehensive heating services for both residential and commercial properties, offering installation, maintenance, repair, replacement, and tune-ups for furnaces, boilers, heat pumps, water heaters, and ductless/mini-split systems, ensuring your heating needs are fully met.
Choosing the right propane companies in Wisconsin is a critical decision that impacts not only the warmth and comfort of your home but also the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of your business or agricultural operations. Our exploration of the state’s top propane companies highlights those that excel in reliability, customer service, affordability, and environmental stewardship.
Whether you prioritize extensive service coverage, flexible pricing plans, or a company’s commitment to community and sustainability, there’s a provider that meets your needs. We encourage you to consider these standout companies for your propane services, confident that they represent the best of what Wisconsin has to offer in terms of energy solutions that are both practical and principled.
