Get dealer quotes on your propane delivery

Propane vs Diesel Generator: Pros and Cons

propane vs diesel generator

From bustling construction sites to vibrant event venues, mobile generators play an indispensable role. These powerhouses light up spaces, operate machinery, keep temperatures comfortable, and ensure the smooth running of sound systems. Plus, in an era of unpredictable weather patterns and power interruptions, both businesses and households increasingly rely on generators as a backup power solution.

Traditionally, diesel generators have been the go-to choice, revered for their durability and efficiency. However, as the world becomes more attuned to environmental concerns, the search for greener alternatives has accelerated. That’s where the propane generator comes in. 

To help you figure out which one suits your needs the best, we put together a breakdown of propane versus diesel generators.

Propane vs diesel generator: How they operate

There are some similarities in how a propane generator works versus a diesel generator. For example, in both, an internal combustion engine is key to converting chemical energy to electrical energy. At the same time, there are notable differences between propane versus diesel generators:

How propane generators work

A propane generator operates by converting chemical energy into mechanical energy, which then gets transformed into electrical energy. At the heart of this mechanism is an internal combustion engine, similar to what you’d find in many cars. When propane is introduced into the generator’s combustion chamber, it’s mixed with air. Upon ignition, this air-fuel mixture combusts, and the resulting explosion pushes a piston within a cylinder. As the piston moves, it turns a crankshaft, initiating a process that drives the generator’s alternator.

The critical component for electricity generation is the alternator. It consists of two main parts: the rotor and the stator. As the crankshaft turns the rotor, a magnetic field is created. This rotating magnetic field induces a flow of electric current in the stator, producing electricity. This electricity is then channeled and distributed to power various appliances and devices. One of the beauties of a propane generator is the cleanliness of its burn compared to some other fuels, leading to fewer emissions and a reduced environmental footprint.

How diesel generators work

At the heart of a diesel generator is also an internal combustion engine. The basic operation begins with the injection of diesel fuel into the combustion chamber. There, it’s mixed with air that has been heated through compression. Due to the high temperature of the compressed air, the diesel fuel ignites without the need for a spark plug. This key difference distinguishes diesel engines from gasoline counterparts. This ignition causes an explosion, pushing a piston within the engine’s cylinder. As the piston moves, it rotates a crankshaft, setting the stage for the generation of electricity.

Connected to the engine’s crankshaft is the alternator. As the rotor spins within the stator, driven by the engine’s crankshaft, it creates a rotating magnetic field. This magnetic activity induces an electric current within the stator, producing electricity.

What are some of the benefits of a propane vs diesel generator?

If you’re trying to decide on a propane versus diesel generator, knowing some of the key benefits is essential. Here are some of the advantages that stand out the most with propane versus diesel generators:

1. Propane is more readily available

Propane is a very accessible fuel source. While diesel and gasoline rely on electric pumps for distribution — a system that can be compromised in power outages — propane remains available even during severe crises. Whether it’s the wrath of ice storms, the fury of hurricanes, or any other natural disaster that disconnects homes from the electrical grid, propane’s availability stays largely unaffected.

Many households opt to keep standard-sized propane tanks on standby. This ensures they’re prepared for sudden power interruptions. These tanks are conveniently available across communities, making them easy to procure. For regions prone to recurrent power disturbances, maintaining an on-site propane storage tank guarantees uninterrupted access to this clean, efficient, and safe energy source throughout the year. Plus, in many places, propane delivery services are available. This helps ensure fuel reaches your doorstep, be it a residence or a business, with minimal hassle. What’s more, you can get quotes from up to 5 propane dealers in your area today to get the best pricing on propane delivery.

2. Propane generators are easy to start up

One of the notable attributes of propane generators is their seamless start-up. In contrast, diesel generators have their set of drawbacks, especially when it comes to starting up in colder conditions. On the other hand, when the lights go out unexpectedly, a propane standby generator jumps into action. It restores power within a few moments. 

Additionally, the reliability of propane as a fuel source is underscored by its long-term stability. Unlike diesel, which may need the addition of fuel additives or face quality degradation over prolonged periods, propane remains consistently ready for use. This way, your generator is always primed for action when needed.

3. Propane generators provide greater longevity and stability

Propane has a longer shelf life compared to diesel and doesn’t degrade over time. Diesel fuel can develop algae or become contaminated if stored for extended periods. This can damage the generator’s engine and reduce its efficiency. In contrast, propane, stored under pressure in tanks, remains stable and retains its quality.  You can count on reliable generator performance even if propane has been stored for long durations. This makes maintenance and long-term use more straightforward with propane generators.

4. Environmental impact of propane is less harmful

One of the standout advantages of propane generators is their eco-friendliness. Propane burns cleaner than diesel fuel. This means that when a propane generator is in operation, it emits fewer harmful pollutants and greenhouse gasses. The reduction in carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxide, and other pollution, makes propane generators a more environmentally conscious choice.

5. Operational noise and maintenance are less of a concern

Propane generators generally operate more quietly compared to their diesel counterparts. Less noise pollution can be especially helpful in residential areas. Furthermore, the cleaner-burning nature of propane means less residue and buildup in the engine. Propane generators often require less frequent maintenance. This leads to potentially lower long-term upkeep costs and longer engine life.

More uses of propane generators

Beyond serving as a backup power source, propane generators have a ton of applications. Construction sites frequently use propane generators to fuel their tools and machinery. Propane’s dependability, coupled with its impressive shelf life, ensures that work remains uninterrupted. Storing propane directly on the site enhances efficiency. It does this by minimizing downtime and ensuring a steady power supply to maintain the momentum of construction.

Similarly, adventurers — from campers to globetrotters — count on propane generators to bring the conveniences of home to their travels. Outdoor events, be it a grand concert or a quaint gathering, benefit immensely from propane generators. They can transform expansive outdoor spaces into illuminated, cozy settings. And unlike their diesel counterparts, propane generators operate with a quieter hum, sparing attendees from the loud drone of engines and leaving no lingering diesel odors.

Propane vs diesel generator safety

Generators play a pivotal role in ensuring power continuity during outages. When it comes to safety, both propane and diesel generators come with their unique set of considerations. 

Propane generators store fuel in sealed, pressurized tanks, reducing the risk of spillage. What’s more, propane is a gas and does not pool like liquid fuels if accidentally released. This is useful in reducing fire hazards.

On the other hand, diesel fuel is less flammable than gasoline and doesn’t ignite as quickly. Yet, diesel generators aren’t without their challenges. Diesel fuel can spill and contaminate the environment. Plus, diesel can develop contaminants if stored for extended periods without proper care. This ultimately affects the generator’s performance and longevity.

Both propane and diesel generators have safety advantages. But they also require specific precautions. It’s essential to understand these nuances to provide safe and efficient operation.

Is a diesel or propane generator better off grid?

For those looking to live or operate off the grid, choosing the right power source is paramount. Diesel generators have traditionally been a popular choice, primarily due to their high efficiency. But there’s an increasing shift towards propane generators, and for several good reasons.

Propane often emerges as a more cost-effective fuel. Even though diesel might boast a higher energy output, the often lower cost of propane can make it a more economical choice in the long run. Propane’s widespread availability means that even in remote areas, replenishing your fuel supply rarely becomes an issue. This accessibility contrasts with diesel, which might not always be readily available in secluded regions.

Another significant advantage of propane generators is the storage aspect. Propane is stored in sealed, pressurized tanks. This makes it safer and more straightforward than storing liquid diesel. The latter is prone to spillage and potential environmental contamination. What’s more, propane’s cleaner-burning nature means less maintenance for the generator, fewer emissions, and a reduced environmental footprint.

While diesel generators have their merits, when considering the overall cost, accessibility, and environmental impact, propane generators often emerge as the superior choice for off-grid living. Indeed, you can get quotes from up to 5 propane dealers in your area today to get the best pricing on propane delivery.

How long will 100 gallons of propane last for a generator?

The duration for which a generator will operate on a given amount of propane largely depends on its power capacity and load. For instance, if you have a 100-gallon propane tank and a 7kW generator, you can expect it to run continuously for approximately 66 hours when it’s operating at its maximum capacity. Conversely, a more powerful 12kW generator drawing from the same 100-gallon tank will have a shorter run time of around 36 hours at full load.

However, in real-world scenarios, generators rarely operate at their maximum capacity continuously. More often than not, they function within a range of 25-75% of their total capacity, depending on the power demands placed upon them. This means that, in practical situations, a 100-gallon propane tank can sustain a generator for a significantly longer duration than the mentioned hours, as the generator’s power consumption will fluctuate and rarely reach its peak for extended periods.

The bottom line on a propane vs diesel generator

When choosing between propane and diesel generators, you need to really understand each fuel’s merits and limitations. Propane generators shine with their eco-friendly emissions, consistent fuel shelf life, and relatively quiet operation. Diesel generators, on the other hand, have earned their longstanding reputation for robustness, fuel efficiency, and longer runtime. Their resilience in demanding situations makes them a staple in many industrial settings.

The decision between propane and diesel isn’t a simple matter of superiority. It’s about aligning the specific advantages of each with the unique requirements at hand. Whether it’s the ecological benefits of propane or the rugged reliability of diesel, understanding the context and desired outcomes will guide users toward the most fitting choice.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *